‘More construction than destruction’: the ambiguous place of architectural heritage in a reconstructing Belfast circa 1972-89
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7480/iphs.2016.4.1303Abstract
The urban landscape of the city of Belfast was radically transformed from the late 1960s by a combination of state-sponsored reconstruction and civil unrest, including paramilitary activity associated with the period in Northern Ireland euphemistically known as the Troubles. This paper explores the sometimes competing and contradictory interpretations of destruction in the built environment as the UK government sought to promulgate a narrative of progressive change in the fortunes of Belfast in the face of a prolonged terrorist campaign, with the discussion partially framed using Vale’s ideas on the social construction of urban resilience. The narrative is illuminated by the case of the Castlecourt development in the heart of the city in the 1980s, which was controversial for its demolition of prominent Victorian-era buildings. The paper addresses the political questions of the ambiguous place of architectural heritage in Belfast circa 1972-89, who dominated power relations in the city, and who benefited from key redevelopment decisions. It provides insights with contemporary resonance into the critical importance of institutional architecture and governance to the setting of government priorities and the application of power in conflicted places.References
Balfour, Jean. A New Look at the Northern Ireland Countryside. Belfast: Her Majesty’s Stationary Office, 1984.
Bardon, Jonathan. “Governing the City.” In Enduring City: Belfast in the Twentieth Century, edited by Frederick W. Boal and Stephen A. Royle, 124-140. Belfast: Blackstaff Press, 2006.
Berry, Jim, and McGreal, Stanley. “Public sector initiatives in the regeneration of Belfast,” In Urban Regeneration: Property Investment and Development, edited by Jim Berry, Stanley McCrea, and Bill Deddis, 193-214. London: E & F N Spon, 1993.
Birrell, Derek. Direct Rule and Governance of Northern Ireland. Manchester: Manchester University Press, 2009.
Brown, Stephen. “Retail location and retail change in Belfast city centre.” PhD Diss., Queen’s University Belfast, 1984.
Brown, Stephen. “Smithfield Shopping Centre, Belfast.” Irish Geography 18 (1985a): 67-69.
Brown, Stephen. “Central Belfast’s security segment: an urban phenomenon.” Area 17 (1985b): 1-9.
Brown, Stephen. “Twenty years of change: retailing in the Belfast region 1969-1989.” In Geographical Perspectives on the Belfast Region, edited by Paul Doherty, 54-67. Newtownabbey: Geographical Society of Ireland, 1990.
Brett, Charles E.B. Buildings of Belfast, 1700-1914. London: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1967.
Brett, Charles E.B. Buildings of Belfast, 1700-1914. Revised Edition, Belfast: Friar’s Bush Press, 1985.
Building Design Partnership. Belfast Central Area: a report to Belfast Corporation on planning policy in the city centre. Belfast: Building Design Partnership, 1969.
Calame, Jon and Charlesworth, Esther. Divided Cities: Belfast, Beirut, Jerusalem, Mostar, and Nicosia. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2009.
Carmichael, Paul. “The Northern Ireland Civil Service: Characteristics and Trends Since 1970.” Public Administration 80 (2002): 23-49.
Cebulla, Andreas. “Urban Policy and Local Economic Interests in Northern Ireland: A City Comparison.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 20 (1996): 466-479.
Coopers & Lybrand Associates. Retail Study: the Belfast Urban Area Plan 1986-2001. Belfast: Department of the Environment for Northern Ireland, 1986.
Cowan, Rob. “Big in Belfast.” Architects’ Journal 190 (1989): 26-31.
Cunningham, Niall. “‘The doctrine of vicarious punishment’: space, religion and the Belfast Troubles of 1920-22.” Journal of Historical Geography 40 (2013): 52-66.
Curtis, Jennifer. “‘Community’ and the Re-Making of 1970s Belfast.” Ethnos 73 (2008): 399-426.
Deddis, William G. and McGreal, Stanley. “Urban regeneration: a comparative assessment – Great Britain and Northern Ireland.” In Land and Property Development – New Directions, edited by Richard Grover, 199-207. London: E & F N Spon, 1989.
Gamboni, Dario. The Destruction of Art: Iconoclasm and Vandalism since the French Revolution. London: Reaktion Books, 1997.
Hannigan, John A. Environmental Sociology. 2nd Edition, London: Routledge, 2006.
Hendry, John, McEldowney, Malachy and Gilbert, Sarah. “Urban development grant: A trigger for economic and environmental regeneration.” Planning Practice and Research 7 (1992): 13-20.
McClelland, Andrew G. “Contesting destruction, construction heritage: the social construction of architectural heritage values in Belfast, circa 1960-1989.” PhD Diss., Ulster University, 2014.
McEldowney, Malachy, Sterrett, Ken W., and Gaffikin, Frank. “Architectural Ambivalence: the built environment and identity in Belfast.” In Urban Planning and Cultural Inclusion: Lessons from Belfast and Berlin, edited by William J.V. Neill and Hanns-Uve Schwedler, 100-117. Basingstoke: Palgrave, 2001.
Mooney, Sam and Gaffikin, Frank. Reshaping Space and Society: A Critical Review of the Belfast Urban Area Plan 2001. Belfast: Belfast Centre for the Unemployed, 1988.
Morrison, Bill. “Making Belfast Work.” The Planner 76 (199): 32-35.
Murray, Russell. “Political violence in Northern Ireland 1969-1977.” In Integration and Division: geographical perspectives on the Northern Ireland problem, edited by Frederick W. Boal and J. Neville H. Douglas, 309-331. London: Academic Press, 1982.
Murtagh, Brendan. “A comparison of two land use planning organisations in Belfast.” PhD Diss., Queen’s University Belfast, 1992.
Murtagh, Brendan, and Shirlow, Peter. “Devolution and the politics of development in Northern Ireland.” Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy 30 (2012): 46-61.
Needham, Richard. Battling for Peace. Belfast: Blackstaff Press, 1998.
Neill, William J.V. “Physical Planning and Image Enhancement: Recent Developments in Belfast.” International Journal of Urban and Regional Research 17 (1993): 595–609.
Patton, Marcus. “Looking Back in Anger.” Ulster Architect (June 1985): 2-5.
Patton, Marcus. Central Belfast: An Historical Gazetteer. Belfast: Ulster Architectural Heritage Society, 1993.
Prince, Simon P. “5 October 1968 and the Beginning of the Troubles: Flashpoints, Riots and Memory.” Irish Political Studies 27 (2012): 394-410.
Royle, Stephen A. Belfast Part II, 1840-1901, Irish Historic Towns Atlas No 17. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy, 2007.
Sterrett, Ken, Hackett, Mark and Hill, Declan. “The social consequences of broken urban structures: a case study of Belfast.” Journal of Transport Geography 21 (2012): 49-61.
Ulster Architectural Heritage Society. Heritage Newsletter. Belfast: Ulster Architectural Heritage Society, 1984.
Ulster Architectural Heritage Society. Heritage Newsletter. Belfast: Ulster Architectural Heritage Society, 1985.
Vale, Lawrence J. “The politics of resilient cities: whose resilience and whose city?.” Building Research & Information 42 (2014): 191-201.
